Measurement of Muscle Hardness Using a Hardness Meter: Application to the Masseter and Temporal Muscles and Reproducibility of Measurement

ABSTRACTThis study was designed to evaluate the intra-examiner and inter-examiner reliability of measurements of masticatory muscle hardness and to confirm that the muscle hardness increases with contraction using a commercially available muscle meter. Twenty healthy asymptomatic female subjects participated in this study. Hardness was expressed as numerical relative values (0–100). First, muscle hardness was measured at a standardized point located in the masseter muscle and temporal muscle in a randomized order by two examiners, and again by one of the same examiners after ten minutes for the reproducibility study. Then the muscle hardness was measured at each point for 0 kgf, 3 kgf, 6 kgf, and 9 kgf levels of bite force. As a result, intradass correlation coefficient (ICC) analysis revealed good intra-examiner reliability in the masseter muscle (ICC = 0.711), good intra-examiner reliability in the temporal muscle (ICC = 0.643), good inter-examiner reliability in the masseter muscle (ICC=0.631), and una...