Markovian exchange phenomena in magnetic resonance and the Lindblad equation

Abstract Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) experiments involve coherent and incoherent dynamics. Incoherent dynamics give rise to nuclear spin relaxation typically accounted for by a differential equation known as a quantum master equation. Out of the existing master equations the Lindblad equation is particularly important. A central theorem of open quantum theory states that a relaxation process represents a quantum Markovian process if and only if it can be described by a Lindblad master equation. This in turn raises serious questions regarding the compatibility of conventional NMR relaxation theory and one of the most fundamental results of open quantum theory. The NMR treatment of important Markovian relaxation mechanisms such as Brownian motion or chemical exchange events do in general not result in a master equation in Lindblad form and would therefore be at odds with the mathematically rigorous theory of open quantum systems. We explore this apparent conflict for two important chemical exchange phenomena and show that their conventional treatment may be recast into a suitable Lindblad equation. Similarities between spatial diffusion and multi-site exchange events allow us to extend our results to nuclear spin relaxation due to translational diffusion. As a result we are able to show that the NMR treatment of intramolecular exchange and translational diffusion represent valid quantum Markovian processes compatible with the rigorous definitions of open quantum theory.