Is Z-disk degradation responsible for postmortem tenderization?

A number of studies have suggested that Z-disk degradation is a major factor contributing to postmortem tenderization. These conclusions seem to have been based largely on experimental findings showing that the calpain system has a major role in postmortem tenderization, and that when incubated with myofibrils or muscle strips, purified calpain removes Z-disks. Approximately 65 to 80% of all postmortem tenderization occurs during the first 3 or 4 d postmortem, however, and there is little or no ultrastructurally detectable Z-disk degradation during this period. Electron microscope studies described in this paper show that, during the first 3 or 4 d of postmortem storage at 4 o C, both costameres and N 2 lines are degraded. Costameres link myofibrils to the sarcolemma, and N 2 lines have been reported to be areas where titin and nebulin filaments, which form a cytoskeletal network linking thick and thin filaments, respectively, to the Z-disk, coalesce. Filamentous structures linking adjacent myofibrils laterally at the level of each Z-disk are also degraded during the first 3 or 4 d of postmortem storage at 4 o C, resulting in gaps between myofibrils in postmortem muscle. Degradation of these structures would have important effects on tenderness. The proteins constituting these structures, nebulin and titin (N 2 lines); vinculin, desmin, and dystrophin (three of the six to eight proteins constituting costameres); and desmin (filaments linking adjacent myofibrils) are all excellent substrates for the calpains, and nebulin, titin, vinculin, and desmin are largely degraded within 3 d postmortem in semimembranosus muscle. Electron micrographs of myofibrils used in the myofibril fragmentation index assay show that these myofibrils, which have been assumed to be broken at their Z-disks, in fact have intact Z-disks and are broken in their I-bands