Contradictory clues as to the origin of the Martian moons

The meager available information that is pertinent to the origin and evolution of the Martian satellites is contradictory. The known physical properties of the Martian moons (density, albedo, color and spectral reflectivity) are similar to those of many C-type asteroids, the dark 'carbonaceous' objects abundant in the outer belt but scarce near Mars; thus this line of physical evidence suggests that Phobos and Deimos are captured bodies. In contrast, calculated histories of orbital evolution due to tides in the planet and in the satellites indicate that these small craggy moons originated on nearly circular, uninclined orbits not far from their current positions; hence dynamicists prefer an origin in circum-Martian orbit. Ways are described in which these apparently contradictory viewpoints may be reconciled, although a definitive answer to the origin of the Martian satellites will almost surely have to await in situ measurements.