Male mating constraints affect mutual mate choice: prudent male courting and sperm-limited females.

Abstract: Costs of sperm production may lead to prudence in male sperm allocation and also to male mate choice. Here, we develop a life history–based mutual mate choice model that takes into account the lost‐opportunity costs for males from time out in sperm recovery and lets mate competition be determined by the prevailing mate choice strategies. We assume that high mating rate may potentially lead to sperm depletion in males, and that as a result, female reproduction may be limited by the availability of sperm. Increasing variation in male quality leads, in general, to increased selective mate choice by females, and vice versa. Lower‐quality males may, however, gain access to more fecund higher‐quality females by lowering their courting rate, thus increasing their sperm reserves. When faced with strong male competition for mates, low‐quality males become less choosy, which leads to assortative mating for quality and an increased mating rate across all males. With assortative mating, the frequency of ant...