Prevalence of squamous abnormalities in women with a recent smear without endocervical cells is lower as compared to women with smears with endocervical cells

The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence rate ratio of squamous lesions in women with recent smears without endocervical component (ECC-) versus women having a smear with ECC+ and to estimate the true prevalence of these lesions in women with ECC- smears by addition of short-term follow-up results of negative ECC- smears. Results of initial smears in a 3-year period, as well as follow-up results of negative ECC- smears in the same period were retrieved. Women were categorized into two groups: having ECC- and ECC+ smears. The data were analysed for three outcome parameters, ASCUS or higher (ASCUS+), LSIL or higher (LSIL+) and HSIL or higher (HSIL+). Squamous abnormalities occurred far less frequently in women with initial ECC- than with ECC+ smears. Prevalence rate ratio (PRR) was 0.27 for ASCUS+, 0.39 for LSIL+ and 0.36 for HSIL+. Addition of follow-up results of negative ECC- smears, as a correction for false-negative ECC- smears, results in PRRs which are still significantly lower than 1, and most marked in subset HSIL+ (PRR = 0.60). We conclude that the true prevalence of squamous lesions in women with recent ECC- smears is significantly lower as compared with ECC+ smears. These findings lent support to the decision to abolish the repeat of ECC- smears in the Dutch population screening programme.