Assessing acute toxicities of pre- and post-treatment industrial wastewaters with Hydra attenuata : a comparative study of acute toxicity with the fathead minnow, Pimephales promelas

This study was undertaken to (a) determine wastewater treatment effectiveness using two freshwater organisms (b) compare acute toxicity results from the two species exposed to the wastewaters, and (c) link acute and potential develop mental toxicity of wastewaters in one organism The acute toxicities of several pretreatment and post treatment industrial waste water samples were evaluated with adult Hydra attenuata (92 or 96 h exposure) and fathead minnows (96 h exposure) The acute LC50s agreed closely when results in Hydra attenuata were compared with those from fathead minnow tests Acute LC50s ranged from 3 to > 100% of sample with hydra, and from 1 0 to > 100% of sample with fathead minnows The results provided strong evidence of treatment effectiveness because toxicity decreased with progressive stages of treatment Previously the Hydra Developmental Toxicity Assay (Hydra Assay) was used as a prescreen mainly for in vitro assessment of developmental toxicity with pure compounds and to prioritize toxicants according to selective toxicity to the developing embryo (A/D ratio) Recently we modified the assay for testing natural waters and wastewaters, hence, some of the wastewater samples also were tested for their developmental toxicity In this case, the relative selective toxicity (A/D ratio) of these wastewater samples ranged from 0 7 to 2 1, indicating that no sample was uniquely toxic to the developing embryo, although acute toxicity was manifested Over all, our results indicate the Hydra Assay functions appropriately in assessments of acute and developmental toxicity of industrial wastewaters and may be a simple and useful tool in a battery of tests for broader scale detection of environmental hazards