Human bone marrow stromal cell confluence: effects on cell characteristics and methods of assessment

Abstract Background aims Ex vivo expansion and serial passage of human bone marrow stromal cells (BMSCs, also known as bone marrow–derived mesenchymal stem cells) is required to obtain sufficient quantities for clinical therapy. The BMSC confluence criteria used to determine passage and harvest timing vary widely, and the impact of confluence on BMSC properties remains controversial. The effects of confluence on BMSC properties were studied and confluence-associated markers were identified. Methods BMSC characteristics were analyzed as they grew from 50% to 100% confluence, including viability, population doubling time, apoptosis, colony formation, immunosuppression, surface marker expression, global gene expression and microRNA expression. In addition, culture supernatant protein, glucose, lactate and pH levels were analyzed. Results Confluence-dependent changes were detected in the expression of several cell surface markers: 39 culture supernatant proteins, 26 microRNAs and 2078 genes. Many of these surface markers, proteins, microRNAs and genes have been reported to be important in BMSC function. The pigment epithelium-derived factor/vascular endothelial growth factor ratio increased with confluence, but 80% and 100% confluent BMSCs demonstrated a similar level of immunosuppression of mixed lymphocyte reactions. In addition, changes in lactate and glucose levels correlated with BMSC density. Conclusions BMSC characteristics change as confluence increases. 100% confluent BMSCs may have compromised pro-angiogenesis properties but may retain their immunomodulatory properties. Supernatant lactate and glucose levels can be used to estimate confluence and ensure consistency in passage and harvest timing. Flow cytometry or microRNA expression can be used to confirm that the BMSCs have been harvested at the appropriate confluence.