Initiation and supervisory processes in schizophrenia and depression.

Clinical studies show that schizophrenic and depressive subjects have problems with daily life activities, and neuropsychological studies tend to explain these problems in terms of a dysexecutive syndrome. Verbal fluency and sentence arrangement are tasks considered to focus on two aspects of the dysexecutive syndrome known as initiation and supervision processes, respectively. In this study, we assessed performance in these two tasks in schizophrenia and depression. Twenty-six schizophrenic subjects (chronic schizophrenia, DSM IV definition) were compared with 26 control subjects balanced for sex, age and educational level, and 16 depressive subjects (major depression episode, DSM IV) were compared with 11 similarly balanced control subjects. Switching and clustering scores were evaluated during a semantic fluency task as two components underlying the initiation and organization processes. Capture errors specific to failure of the supervisory system and differences between the number of correct responses in two conditions (valid/invalid) were evaluated as indexes of the supervision process in a sentence arrangement task. In the semantic fluency task, switching scores were significantly lower in the schizophrenic and depressive subjects than in their respective controls. In the sentence arrangement task, only the schizophrenic subjects made significantly more capture errors than their controls and had significantly fewer correct sequences in invalid conditions than in valid conditions. This study shows a dissociation between supervision and initiation processes in two different psychiatric populations. Initiation is impaired, but supervision is preserved in depression, whereas both initiation and supervision are impaired in schizophrenia.