Social organization variation and behavioural flexibility in the facultative cleaning goby Elacatinus prochilos

Social species often show intraspecific variation in the size and composition of their social units, i.e. the social organization. This variation represents a challenge for comparative studies trying to understand evolutionary transitions in social organization complexity. Most studies on intraspecific variation in social organization (IVSO) have focused on the environmental factors selecting for variation in social organization but the mechanisms underlying such variation remain relatively unexplored. Here we investigated the potential mechanisms giving rise to IVSO in the Caribbean cleaning goby Elacatinus prochilos. This small reef fish typically exhibits two types of social organization, pair living or group living, which not only differ in group size but also in feeding strategy and social behaviour. Pair-living gobies cooperatively feed on ectoparasites removed from larger visiting fish, while group-living gobies feed on microinvertebrates living inside sponges and aggressively defend the best feeding spots against each other. We tested how flexible the social organization, social structure and competition over a food source of E. prochilos are by experimentally manipulating group composition, habitat structure and feeding condition of pair-living and group-living wild adult gobies in laboratory. Despite having different original social organizations in the wild, both pair-living and group-living gobies formed dominance hierarchies and exhibited affiliative behaviours in our group manipulations. This indicates that IVSO in this species is not driven by pre-determined or early-developed mechanisms, but rather a consequence of flexibility in social organization, also known as social flexibility.