Endothelial glycocalyx detection and characterization by means of Atomic Force Spectroscopy: comparison of various data analysis approaches

Abstract In recent years, atomic force spectroscopy (AFS) has been used to detect and characterize the endothelial glycocalyx (eGlx) in in vitro and ex vivo experiments. Several analysis methods were proposed, which differ not only in the numerical implementations, but also in physical models of glycocalyx description. Therefore, it is difficult to directly relate the experiments performed by different groups. In this work, we compared different models used for quantitative analysis of atomic force spectroscopy datasets recorded for eGlx. To capture glycocalyx at various structural conditions, we used basic enzymatic protocols for glycocalyx removal and restoration in human aortal endothelial cells (HAEC). Nanoindentation experiments for this model system were performed for (i) untreated cells, (ii) for cells after heparinase incubation, which enzymatically removes glycocalyx, (iii) for cells with successive heparin treatment, which partially restores the glycocalyx layer. Analysis of nanoindentation data was performed using different models: (a) a single-layer contact mechanics, (b) a double-layer model contact mechanics, (c) a polymer “brush” two-layer model based on the Alexander – de Gennes theory and (d) a simple single-layer “mechanical spring” model. Although different physical parameters are evaluated in methods (a–d), we show that all approaches revealed similar qualitative changes of the glycocalyx layer, which reflected the processes of glycocalyx degradation and its partial restoration. This paper may facilitate a direct comparison of past and future glycocalyx oriented AFS experiments that are analysed with different approaches.