Conventional techniques (3D-CRT) for craniospinal irradiation (CSI) are still widely used. Modern techniques (IMRT, VMAT, TomoTherapy®, proton pencil beam scanning [PBS]) are applied in a limited number of centers. For a 14-year-old patient, we aimed to compare dose distributions of five CSI techniques applied across Europe and generated according to the participating institute protocols, therefore representing daily practice. A multicenter (n = 15) dosimetric analysis of five different techniques for CSI (3D-CRT, IMRT, VMAT, TomoTherapy®, PBS; 3 centers per technique) was performed using the same patient data, set of delineations and dose prescription (36.0/1.8 Gy). Different treatment plans were optimized based on the same planning target volume margin. All participating institutes returned their best treatment plan applicable in clinic. The modern radiotherapy techniques investigated resulted in superior conformity/homogeneity-indices (CI/HI), particularly in the spinal part of the target (CI: 3D-CRT:0.3 vs. modern:0.6; HI: 3D-CRT:0.2 vs. modern:0.1), and demonstrated a decreased dose to the thyroid, heart, esophagus and pancreas. Dose reductions of >10.0 Gy were observed with PBS compared to modern photon techniques for parotid glands, thyroid and pancreas. Following this technique, a wide range in dosimetry among centers using the same technique was observed (e.g., thyroid mean dose: VMAT: 5.6–24.6 Gy; PBS: 0.3–10.1 Gy). The investigated modern radiotherapy techniques demonstrate superior dosimetric results compared to 3D-CRT. The lowest mean dose for organs at risk is obtained with proton therapy. However, for a large number of organs ranges in mean doses were wide and overlapping between techniques making it difficult to recommend one radiotherapy technique over another.
ConclusionThe use of VMAT technique is associated with less radiation doses to the remaining kidney and better coverage to the PTV than 3D-CRT technique for WAI, with preliminary clinical experience showing favorable toxicity profile.Long-term results from prospective studies might prove the ability of VMAT to spare renal function in the setting of WT treatment.
Inhomogeneities in radiotherapy dose distributions covering the vertebrae in children can produce long-term spinal problems, including kyphosis, lordosis, scoliosis, and hypoplasia. In the published literature, many often interrelated variables have been reported to affect the extent of potential radiotherapy damage to the spine. Articles published in the 2D and 3D radiotherapy era instructed radiation oncologists to avoid dose inhomogeneity over growing vertebrae. However, in the present era of highly conformal radiotherapy, steep dose gradients over at-risk structures can be generated and thus less harm is caused to patients. In this report, paediatric radiation oncologists from leading centres in 11 European countries have produced recommendations on how to approach dose coverage for target volumes that are adjacent to vertebrae to minimise the risk of long-term spinal problems. Based on available information, it is advised that homogeneous vertebral radiotherapy doses should be delivered in children who have not yet finished the pubertal growth spurt. If dose fall-off within vertebrae cannot be avoided, acceptable dose gradients for different age groups are detailed here. Vertebral delineation should include all primary ossification centres and growth plates, and therefore include at least the vertebral body and arch. For partial spinal radiotherapy, the number of irradiated vertebrae should be restricted as much as achievable, particularly at the thoracic level in young children (< 6 years old). There is a need for multicentre research on vertebral radiotherapy dose distributions for children, but until more valid data become available, these recommendations can provide a basis for daily practice for radiation oncologists who have patients that require vertebral radiotherapy.
Proton radiation therapy is a form of external radiation that uses charged particles which have distinct physical advantages to deliver the majority of its dose in the target while minimizing the dose of radiation to normal tissues. In children who are particularly susceptible even at low and medium doses of radiation, the significant reduction of integral dose can potentially mitigate the incidence of side effects and improve quality of life. The aim of the first part of the thesis is to describe the physical and radiobiological properties of protons, the Proton Therapy Center of Trento (TCPT) active for clinical purpose since 2014, which use the most recent technique called active pencil beam scanning. The second part of the thesis describes the preliminary clinical results of 23 pediatric patients with central nervous system tumors as well as of two aggressive pediatric meningiomas treated with pencil beam scanning. All the patients were particularly well-suited candidates for proton therapy (PT) for possible benefits in terms of survival and incidence of acute and late side effects. We reported also a multicentric experience of 27 medulloblastoma patients (median age 6 years, M/F ratio 13/14) treated between 2015 and 2020 at TPTC coming from three Pediatric oncology centers: Bologna, Florence, and Ljubljana, with a focus on clinical results and toxicities related to radiotherapy (RT). Proton therapy was associated with mostly mild acute and late adverse effects and no cases of CNS necrosis or high grade of neuroradiological abnormailities. Comparable rates of survival and local control were obtained to those achievable with conventional RT. Finally, we performed a systematic review to specifically address the safety of PT for pediatric CNS patients, late side effects and clinical effectiveness after PT in this patient group.
